High Minded Theology Versus the Lives of Lay People


A faculty member in the Catholic setting recently reviewed the separation between Catholic academics who train priests and the changing world of religion. I think it applies not only to the Catholic denomination but to many Protestant ones as well.

I read the link twice and am not certain I understand it completely. The author, a professor of theology, laments several developments taking place.

He laments that students entering seminary studies have less grounding in academic theology than in past generations. But, seminaries are devoting less training in theology than in the past. It's importance has slipped over time.

At the same time outside the seminary there are ever increasing headwinds for the church. Students, he said, are not being trained to move into those headwinds and compete.

The smaller colleges which provided deeper training in the denomination's theological tenets train few students, are becoming smaller and some are closing. Larger Catholic research universities are not set up to train seminary students in Catholic theology but are to train them about it. My own guess it this means professors are required to publish and the easiest thing to publish is an article that splits theological hairs and does nothing to advance the future of the denomination.

He points out that new clergy will be required more than their predecessors to work with lay people. Little training, he says, is being provided for that.

It seems to me Christianity of several stripes, Catholic and Protestant, would help itself by accepting the public does not buy what it is selling like it used to. Instead of trying to sell the old tonic, it should say, "Let's set aside some of our old stuff like homosexual sin, abortion sin and pushing ourselves into laws. Then, let's find common ground with non believers to help the less fortunate."

Comments

  1. This kind of / sort of /corresponds with an article I read not too long ago by a seminary student. They sounded disappointed the main thrust of their training was in philosophy, and light in theology. More in form than in content.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I could add more pages to this, but the simple statement of; "The more things change, the more they remain the same". Does "word smithing" ring a bell? A tool of philosophy.

      Delete
    2. Different seminaries have different experiences. Then again, he might be at a seminary that starts out with classical philosophy and then moves on to Catholic theology. It is quite true that some seminaries are more orthodox than modern; orthodox being the correct approach.

      I imagine a good course in heresies and apostasies would be a great way to show the value of orthodox theology.

      Delete
  2. A priest is there to represent Jesus Christ, God and the Holy Spirit and to administer the Sacraments to the faithful. Baptize, hear confessions, consecrate and distribute the Eucharist, marry, confirm, anoint the sick and (for bishops), ordain priests.

    If there is a loss of faith in the public, or in the priesthood, it is understandable. Catholics take up the Cross in everyday life. Being a Christian is hard work and sacrifice. No wonder people don't want to be blessed with faith! The Devil provides temptations by the thousands; porn, avarice, pride, gluttony, envy, etc.

    We live in an age where technology has captured the minds, hearts of souls of many people. Technology should be a tool, not a god. Porn on your smartphone behind a VPN, etc. It's as easy as opening the frig or turning on the tube.

    Unless God is very, very merciful, it seems the majority of people are headed for hell. Personally, I hope he is very, very merciful but I will live my life humbly and quietly, hoping for His mercy for me and mine.

    BTW, the priests in the Fargo diocese and at my parish, Sts. Anne and Joachim, are very orthodox and wonderful. Fargo's Catholic churches seem to be thriving.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Theology aids the "lives of lay people" by helping to create a formal and unerring teaching. In that respect, theology is anything but "high minded". And theology is not the opponent of the lay people; a childish straw man. I really enjoy theology and I am a lay man. I know lots of Catholics and this faux tempest in the non-existent teapot would not make the top 1000 of issues Catholics are concerned with. If you really want to be relevant, why not discuss the existence of 2 popes? Or bring up the topic of an "Imperfect Council"?

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Maybe the "Original Sin" Should be Reassigned

The Religious Capitol Invaders May Yet Win

Father Frank Pavone, the Ultimate Crook